I scream. You scream. We all scream for ICE CREAM….especially in Gilbert when it's 100 degrees out. BUT who am I kidding? I could go for a delicious ice cream cone during all weather conditions. Check out this list of the best ice cream shops in and near Gilbert, Arizona!
This site contains affiliate links to products. I may receive a commission for purchases made through these links at no extra cost to you.
Best Ice Cream in Gilbert
Handels Homemade Ice Cream
Located throughout the United States, Handel’s is known for some of the best-tasting homemade Ice Cream. We are lucky enough to have a location right in Gilbert!
The ice cream is made fresh in the store each morning, and with over 40 choices, you’ll surely find something that hits the spot. You can even order a sampler which will give you 4 different rich and creamy flavors to enjoy!
Handels Homemade Ice Cream Quick Facts
- Hours: 11:00 am-9:00 pm (10:00 pm on Fridays and Saturdays)
- Physical Address: 1672 E Guadalupe Rd Gilbert, Arizona 85234
- Flavors and choices: 39+ flavors + Flavored Ices, Sherberts, and Vegan Sorbet options
Petersen’s Ice Cream and Cafe
Petersen’s is a local gem nestled in the heart of downtown Gilbert. It’s beautifully decorated with a vintage vibe. They have a small indoor seating area with additional seats outside. You can choose between cones, shakes, malts, or my personal favorite the ice cream sandwich bar. You can mix and match your cookies and the filling inside your sandwich. Chocolate chip cookie with vanilla topped with a brownie anyone?
Petersen’s Ice Cream and Cafe Quick Facts:
- Hours: 1:00 pm-9:30 pm (Mon-Thursday), 1:00 pm- 11:00 pm (Fridays), 12:00 pm- 11:00 pm (Saturdays), and 12:00 pm- 9:30 pm (Sundays)
- Physical Address: 366 N Gilbert Rd, Gilbert, AZ, United States, Arizona
- Flavors and choices: 25+ Flavors, + Icecream Sandwiches, Shakes, Malts, sundaes, and even a donut ice cream sandwich option!
212 Ice Cream Studio
212 Ice Cream Studio strives to bring you delicious (and homemade) ice cream AND an unforgettable experience. You can order unique ice cream rolls with delicious mix-ins or stick with the tried and true cone or float. If you are feeling extra adventurous, be sure to try one of 212’s specialty sundaes…they even have one served in an edible cereal cup!
212 Ice Cream Studio Quick Facts:
- Hours: 1:00-9:00 pm (10:00 pm on Fridays and Saturdays)
- Physical Address: 3305 E Williamsfield Rd Gilbert 85295
- Flavors and Choices: Rolls, Cones (pretzel and cookie cones as well), Floats, and Sundaes with hundreds of mix-in combinations! There are vegan and sugar-free options available!
Creamistry
Creamistry uses the unique process of flash-freezing each ice cream order with liquid nitrogen. This leaves a super fresh and rich taste on demand!
You start by choosing your base and can decide between a dairy, vegan, or fruit sorbet base. Then you choose your ice cream flavor and toppings. The combinations are endless! Creamistry also offers signature creations for those of you who get overwhelmed with too many choices… (Maybe that’s just me… I can never decide if I’m feeling like fruit or chocolate mix-ins).
Creamistry Quick Facts
- Hours: 12:00-9:00 pm (10:00 pm on Fridays and Saturdays)
- Physical Address: 335 N. Gilbert Rd Suite 101 Gilbert, AZ 85234
- Flavors and Choices: 3 base choices, 23+ flavors, and 30+ mix-in options.
Cream of the Crop
Cream of the Crop is a local gem that is slightly less overwhelming (in choices) than the above options. With just eight choices to choose from, this shop prides itself on perfecting each recipe. I am hoping to try the Secret Breakfast flavor next which includes bourbon-flavored ice cream! You can turn these delicious flavors into a banana split or float as well!
Cream of the Crop Quick Facts:
- Hours: 12:00 pm-9:00 pm (Mon-Thursday), 12:00 pm- 9:30 pm (Friday), 11:00 am- 9:30 pm (Saturdays), Closed on Sundays.
- Physical Address: 3000 E Ray Rd Building 6, suite 103, Gilbert, AZ 85296
- Flavors and Choices: 24+ local flavors of Italian Ice + soft serve ice cream
Best Gelato In Gilbert
Frost: A Gelato Shoppe
When you need a break from the creamy classic ice cream, head to Frost for some authentic Italian Gelato. Located in the SanTan Village, you’ll find numerous options for homemade gelato and sorbet. You can mix and match the flavors to make the perfect combination!
Frost: A Gelato Shoppe Quick Facts:
- Hours: 11:00 am-10:00 pm (11:00 pm on Fridays and Saturdays)
- Physical Address: 2150 E Williams Field Rd, Ste 120 Gilbert, AZ 85295
- Flavors and Choices: Gelato, Sorbets, shakes, and coffee drinks.
Gelato64
Gelato64 prides itself on offering the widest variety of unique Gelato flavors in ALL of Arizona. You can choose between one-of-a-kind flavors such as Key Lime Pie or Death By Chocolate! If looking to support a family-owned local business, be sure to add this to your Gilbert Ice Cream Bucket list (that’s a thing…right?!)
Gelato64 Quick Facts:
- Hours: 2:30-9:00 (Thursdays and Fridays), 11:30 am- 9:00 pm (Saturdays and Sundays) Closed Monday-Wedesday.
- Physical Address: 4764 S. Higley Rd. Suite 105 Gilbert, AZ 85297
- Flavors and Choices: 24+ unique Gelato flavors
Best Italian Ice in Gilbert
Jeremiah’s Italian Ice
Although not nearly as popular as classic creamy ice cream or gelato, Italian Ice is the perfect way to cool down on a hot summer day. Jeremiah’s Italian Ice has over 24 flavors to choose from so you’ll likely have to keep coming back! You can even mix in soft serve ice cream with your ice to give it a creamier taste…they call it The Gelati!
Jeremiah’s Italian Ice Quick Facts:
- Hours: 12:00pm-10:00 pm (11:00 pm on Fridays and Saturdays)
- Physical Address: 85 E Warner Rd #104 Gilbert, Arizona 85296
- Flavors and Choices: 24+ local flavors of Italian Ice + soft serve ice cream
So there you have it, eight of the very best ice cream shops in Gilbert. After all that ice cream talk, I’m definitely craving a banana spilt now!
If you would like your business featured on All Things Gilbert (or if you would like to recommend your favorite ice cream in Gilbert), send me a message at [email protected]!
Save this image on Pinterest for when you are looking for the best ice cream shops in Gilbert, AZ!
